Why do we still need project management when we have agile frameworks ?
Introduction
The necessity of project management in the context of Agile frameworks is a topic of significant importance. While Agile frameworks offer a robust approach for managing projects, especially in dynamic and uncertain environments, they do not eliminate the need for project management. Even if there are also agile best practices to cope with the knowledge areas of project managers, that doesn't mean that they are covered, or incorporated in the skills of the agile practitioners. You don't learn these PM knowledge areas in a few months. They need, as always, time to build up experience, knowledge, insights so you become more mature and are able to bend them to your needs.
Here are some strong, clear, and logical arguments that elucidate why project management is still essential even in the presence of Agile frameworks:
​
1. Scope and Strategic Alignment:
Holistic View: Project management provides a broader, holistic view of the project, ensuring that it aligns with the strategic goals and objectives of the organization. Agile frameworks, while efficient in handling specific components or iterations of a project, may not always address the wider organizational perspective, or the agile practitioners may not always have the skills nor the experience to provide this holistic view.
Scope Management: Traditional project management plays a crucial role in defining and managing the scope of the project. Even in Agile projects, scope creep can be a risk, and project management techniques help to keep the project focused and aligned with its initial objectives. There are very good agile techniques that can prevent or deal with scope creep, but that doesn't mean that they are incorporated in the skills of the product owner.
​
2. Resource Allocation and Optimization:
Cross-Project Resource Management: Organizations often run multiple projects simultaneously, requiring a coordinated approach to resource allocation. Project management ensures optimal use of resources across various projects, which is beyond the scope of individual Agile teams. In an agile context you could argue that product teams can eliminate this burden, but than these product teams should be in place and working according to the satisfaction of the stakeholders, which is often not yet the case.
Budget Management: Project management is essential for budgeting and controlling costs, ensuring that the project remains financially viable and within the approved budget.
​
3. Risk Management:
Comprehensive Risk Analysis: While Agile frameworks are adept at managing risks within the immediate scope of the project iterations, project management provides a more comprehensive risk analysis, considering long-term and external risks that could impact the project.
Mitigation Strategies: Project management methodologies offer structured approaches to risk mitigation, ensuring that risks are systematically identified, analysed, and managed at the project level.
​
4. Stakeholder Communication and Management:
Broad Stakeholder Engagement: Agile frameworks focus on customer and team communication, but project management extends this communication to a wider range of stakeholders, including sponsors, higher management, and external parties.
Expectation Management: Managing the expectations of various stakeholders, especially those not directly involved in day-to-day development, is a critical aspect of project management.
​
5. Integration and Coordination:
Multiple Teams and Frameworks: In larger organizations, multiple teams may work on different aspects of a project, possibly using different methodologies (Agile, Waterfall, etc.). Project management is crucial for integrating and coordinating these efforts to ensure a cohesive and unified approach.
Change Management: Effective management of changes, whether they are scope changes, resource changes, or strategic pivots, requires a structured approach. Project management methodologies provide the tools and processes for effective change management.
​
6. Quality Assurance and Compliance:
Standardization and Quality: Project management methodologies often come with established standards and procedures that ensure a consistent level of quality across all aspects of a project.
Regulatory Compliance: For projects in regulated industries, compliance with legal and regulatory requirements is non-negotiable. Project management plays a critical role in ensuring that projects comply with these requirements.
​
7. Long-term Perspective and Sustainability:
Future Roadmap: Agile frameworks excel in managing the present and near future of a project but may lack a long-term perspective. Project management helps in planning the future roadmap of a project beyond the immediate iterations.
Sustainable Development: Balancing the demands of rapid Agile development with the need for sustainable, long-term project growth and team well-being is a crucial role of project management.
​
8. Scaling Agile Practices:
Scaling Frameworks: Agile frameworks like Scrum are often designed for small to medium-sized teams. Project management methodologies are crucial when scaling Agile practices for larger teams and projects, ensuring consistency and coordination across various teams.
​
9. Documentation and Knowledge Management:
Record-Keeping: Comprehensive documentation, often emphasized more in traditional project management, is vital for maintaining a record of decisions, changes, and project evolution. This is essential not only for current stakeholders but also for future reference and learning.
Knowledge Sharing: Project management methodologies often incorporate structured approaches to knowledge management, ensuring that insights and learning from the project are captured and shared effectively.
​
Conclusion:
In essence, while Agile frameworks are highly effective in managing projects that are complex, dynamic, and require rapid adaptability, they operate most effectively within the broader structure provided by project management. Project management complements Agile by ensuring strategic alignment, comprehensive resource and risk management, wide-ranging stakeholder engagement, quality and compliance assurance, and a long-term sustainable approach to project development. The combination of Agile methodologies and traditional project management practices leads to a more balanced, comprehensive, and effective approach to managing projects in diverse environments. This synergy ensures that while the agility and responsiveness of the Agile frameworks are maximized, the project remains aligned with the overall strategic goals, is well-coordinated, and meets the quality, compliance, and sustainability standards required for long-term success.